Discussion about this post

User's avatar
sunshine moonlight's avatar

DC think tanks seem to be suited to providing concrete policy analysis and advice. What's lacking is a new vision for the right, especially a post-MAGA and post-Great Awokening direction. If you succeed in creating a metapolitical idea space, big developments could occur. CSPI could also be useful in bringing together eclectic voices and integrating young writers with high human capital who need it cultivated.

Expand full comment
Contarini's avatar

Good pivot. Wise.

Like Hanania, I have a mix of "Yes, right on!" and violent disagreement with what you have published here. A movement requires some degree of intellectual subordination, with everyone on message. You won't get that, and you don't need it.

For example, lots of otherwise decent people won't want to buy into a movement that wants stupid normies and their fat, ugly wives to be law-abiding and nice and productive so that a groovy, nihilistic elite can enjoy depraved sex without the vibe being ruined. The mass appeal is just not there.

Another example: I sent your shame-on-you-Prolifers to some of my Pro-life pals, prefacing it with, this guy is kind of a dick, and I don't always agree with him, but this piece has a lot of ugly truth that will hurt and needs to be heard.

A scene allows a variegated and unstructured conversation, and a search for shared views on particular things, without ever having to march in step.

Looking forward to what you come up with here.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts