Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Field Observer's avatar

Another Zoomer here - whilst a lot of your analysis here is sound, as well as your inaccurate characterisation of Zoomer friendships (as the other commenter said, pushback doesn’t come from friends, it’s a continuously ambient part of the environment with your friends being your copilots navigating it), you have also totally misjudged the Malfoid impact on the basis of misjudging your generation’s own relationships with the books relative to ours.

For Millennials, Harry Potter started coming out when they are about 11 - they read through one book at a time as they come out, and by the time it’s finished they’re 16 and it’s now a foundational point in their life. For Zoomers, the entire book series was out by the time they are old enough to read it. They’ve already read the whole thing by the time they’re 11, at which point it was tossed into the the same box as the Hunger Games, Percy Jackson and all other childhood book series as the ‘pleasant ambient childhood entertainment’ thing and isn’t thought about at all again. If you want actual formative content, look at stuff like Star Wars: The Clone Wars when they were tweens and a bunch of pre-existing stuff like BATAS and Breaking Bad that they proceeded to venerate in their teens, none of which is remotely how you describe at all.

The state of Harry Potter isn’t symptomatic of idealised male dynamics because most young men have barely thought about Harry Potter since they were 12. What Malfoid is instead is the sudden realisation of the exact fantasy you describe, because A: for Zoomer males all entertainment must be couched in existing symbols (Batman, Star Wars etc) to be validating, and B: whilst your account of desired Male/Female dynamics is exactly what their fantasy is, unlike Millennials thanks to Gen X’s need to never be sexist, they have never actually experienced this fantasy validated in any sort of media, and so Malfoid is their first ever experience of having this validated by an existing property

Uber Keats's avatar

Malfoid makes sense from a real-world perspective when you consider that the people who peddle it have never been bullied in their lives because we banned bullying. And so to project any kind of personal experience onto the books as they read them, they project the concept of The Simp—because they are simps.

33 more comments...

Ready for more?