11 Comments
User's avatar
Warmek's avatar

Nice. I guess my dad did all right with my little sister (first era of Millenielle to my last era of Gen X), since she got married young and started popping out nieces and nephews for me before she let *too* many guys blow out her asshole. I mean, I know there were a couple, but she was married by 21, and she tended towards longer relationships before she met Hubby (who is a lawyer, so they can actually support those seven kids) so I'm presuming her body count is a hell of a lot lower than mine.

> Thus as a rule Gen X men learned to shut up about their feels.

Which, in the long run, has done us very little good. We don't whine constantly, but the healthiest of us *have* at least managed to figure out how to talk about that shit with a couple close friends of approximately the same generation, and even on very rare occasions with millennials and zoomers. Which is a useful skill to have as a Gen X Uncle Warmek. Lets us provide semi-useful Uncleoid Advice.

No kids of my own, which is good because I'd probably go insane over the way kids act these days if I did. But I can totally see what you mean about Gen X Girldads. But let's face it, Zoomettes actually *are* dumb. The only way to deal with them when they say retarded shit is to bluntly tell them that they're wrong.

I look forward to your analysis of Millennial Girldads to come. They definitely exist, my brother-in-law *is* one. With two girls who left the house, even though one of them came back. 🤣

Aristides's avatar

This just reminds me how hard it will be to raise teenagers and older.

Richard Heathen's avatar

Thank the gods I'm married. If I wasn't, I would legit become a monk.

Warmek's avatar

It's the only sane choice.

247spam's avatar

gens alternate back and forth between idealist/pragmatist

Patrick Debateman's avatar

I didn’t read your article but I liked it for Marcus Fenix

Field Observer's avatar

Lol, it’s genuinely both fascinating and hilarious reading this as a zoomer - I’m increasingly realising just how dominated by Millennials and above this platform is given this is the state of analysis on the matter. Don’t get me wrong, your accounts of Millennials are absolutely spot on and there are lots of individual observations on Gen Z and Gen X in your posts which have some merit, but this is arguably being outweighed by how confidently wrong you are on the macro narratives.

Gen X didn’t have the stuffing beaten out of them for expressing feelings, they aren’t confrontational and they’re not predominantly aiming at nonchalance - these are all projections of boomer culture onto them or otherwise misreading the situation. The defining trait of Gen X men isn’t professed nonchalance, but instead a deep and abiding earnestness.

Most Gen Xers are growing in a generation where narratively everyone is just about accepting the theoretical equality between men and women (and so for them doing so comes naturally), but in practice the scales are still pretty clearly skewed towards men and hence most feminist efforts are oriented towards resolving these rather than branching out into male issues. From an emotional perspective, it isn’t that the Gen X man was beaten up for talking about their feelings, but instead that the idea of talking about their feelings simply wasn’t something they did or were involved in at all; from a narrative perspective meanwhile, men are still being depicted as the coolest and most competent without needing caveats, or major criticism, whilst despite being meant to be equal, women still clearly aren’t. The net result of this is that for the most part the Gen X man is pretty secure and functional in of himself, but can clearly identify both unjust seeming deficits in how women are depicted, and also ways in which his lack of emotional openness in childhood probably wasn’t helpful.

From this, you essentially get what is a full, unironic earnestness in simply trying to what feels like the right thing and correct wrongs of the past. Gen X men are probably the most ‘baggage-free’ of any major demographic active at the moment and instead just genuinely want everyone to get along and do cool things, which is great for enthusiasm but comes at the cost of having relatively little depth and a total inability to comprehend cringe. Couple this with Gen X women, and you get the ultimate Gen X relationship fantasy: a suave and slightly roguish action hero with excellent skills who rescues the civilian woman, but who is nonetheless able to be put in his place by said woman who nonetheless falls for him on her own terms rather than his, with the whole thing having a completely shameless sense of debonair cool to it. If you want to understand the true distillation of what appeals to Gen X, look at Top Gun and Tony Blair.

For Gen Z women the defining trait isn’t affective sovereignty (again a projection of millennials traits), it’s a persistent, constant state of overwhelm. Their life is essentially a non-stop bombardment of demands, texts, anxieties, drama, scary news reports, deadlines etc, paired with an empowerment narrative that precludes an easy way out. On the one hand, they are fairly similar to Gen X men in that they have received enough narrative support already not to have much of an ego - having already been boosted in childhood, Gen X men had zero qualms about depicting women as hyper competent and men as slightly bumbling so as to fully counteract any antifeminist messages their daughters might receive (inadvertently setting up substantial problems for Gen Z men which I’ll save for another time). On the other hand, they nonetheless constantly feel at the end of their tether and utterly unable to deal with the constant barrage of everything landing on their doorstep.

The need for affective sovereignty therefore isn’t an need in of itself, so much as a defence mechanism lifted from Millennial elders against the constant onslaught of modern life (even if you have your own matters under control, there are about a bazillion scary news stories to get agitated about). In reality, all most Gen Z women really want to do is simply curl into a ball and have someone else make their problems go away until they are manageable again (ideally being able to keep for them a narrative of competence of their own in the process). Gen X dads meanwhile don’t want to avoid indulgence, but instead completely the opposite - the idea of a Gen X dad not being emotionally open enough for their kids to talk to them and for them to instead suffer like they did is so utterly mortifying to said dad they’ll be willing to do anything to prevent it, even if their complete lack of experience in this area renders them hopelessly out of their depth. Thus you end up with the same situation you describe but with the opposite dynamics - the Gen Z woman’s manipulation is generally more subconscious than intentional and borne of desperation rather than Machiavellian instincts, and the Gen X dad’s response is to panic and desperately rattle through every response aimed at helping without infantilising her, before finally giving up and simply throwing his wallet at the problem.

Of course, the real solution to this lies in the form of the ultimate Gen Z relationship fantasy, which consists of an already established to be competent action woman who is nonetheless overwhelmed by forces even she can’t handle, with her then subsequently being rescued by the brooding but even more competent male action hero, who solves her practical problems for her whilst she returns the favour with long deprived emotional affirmation (effectively the Gen X setup with the status dynamics flipped). Gen X wants Batman and Catwoman, Millenials want Superman and Wonder Woman, and Gen Z wants Batman and Wonder Woman; unfortunately Gen X creators at best miss the point slightly with their output, whilst Millennial creators represent quite possibly the absolute worst thing you could be feeding to Gen Zers given their own neuroses, hence why it probably isn’t until Gen Z finally become the media class themselves that you might finally see a piece of media that genuinely captivates that generation.

NeonPatriarch's avatar

Shit, I guess I'm Gen X somehow (I'm technically a Millenial), because all of that cuts way too close to the bone for me, in regards to how I operate myself, how I operate with my daughter, and how my daughter operates herself.

Uncanny.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 30Edited
Comment deleted
Warmek's avatar

The distinction would be that to a Zoomette, the Millennial Theater Kid is now in the sweet spot to be the Older Man. Though it's uncertain how many of them will have the aplomb to pull it off.

Thin Skin Alex's avatar

I’m thinking, and I’ll make the bet that being a millennial theatre kid gives you access to quality and quantity of lovers that is far better than statistical norms.

Plum Chrysanthemum's avatar

My IQ is ~160 and I don't want to be a Daddy or anything like that, in fact the thought repulses me. I want someone I find very beautiful who matches my own wits and has a "world to win" for the good of all souls.