28 Comments
User's avatar
Jeff's avatar

Walt, you really found your fastball on this one. I would not have initially suspected that Hermione analysis from a millenial theater kid hopped up on adderall could’ve been this gripping.

forumposter123@protonmail.com's avatar

I didn’t read the books growing up but have Ben doing so with my girls now. We make them read the books, then we listen to the audiobooks, then they can watch the movie.

Around the fourth movie I really couldn’t take it anymore. Too much cut. Just did not feel at all like the same experience. The first two movies are kids movies, and goofy Ron didn’t bother me. The third movie I think everyone considers the best overall so you roll with it. It’s just a train wreck after that.

Did you know that Rowling sold her film rights to the first four movies for a measly $2 million. This is a woman that in general kept creative and IP control and obviously got very rich, we forget how quickly she went from desperately poor single mom to ultra famous.

The HBO series looks atrocious. Even leaving aside the race stuff, I can tell by the color palette it’s going to be bad. A faithful book adaptation would be great, but it ain’t going to happen. I’m not planning to let my kids watch.

AG Johnson's avatar

I like all of the movies (7 is the closest to not being good), but I know what you mean. The worst offender is the sixth film, because it cuts so much from the book that certain plot points in the film don’t make that much sense. The entire half blood prince plotline feels like a rushed afterthought.

zea mays's avatar

Harry was always a sexless Christlike figure not made to be defiled by womanly hands. Not capable of romantic passion, the kind of guy who saves the life of his rival. I would hate to be in a lovers tiff with that man and have him stare at me benevolently and sorrowfully constantly making me feel like the bad guy. But Jo didnt really do anything for Ron. He was poor and bad at school and unco-ordinated at quidditch AND a coward. Time and time again throughout the story the only credit he ever got was "being a good friend" which, you may have said sidekick. Agree with your Rupert take but Jo didnt do him any favors.

Warmek's avatar

I recall there being a fair bit of online whinging when the first movie came out *because* Emma Watson was... well, being rather older than you, hopefully you'll forgive me for not calling an 11 year old "hot" -- since I was 25 at the time -- but at the very least "conventionally attractive". And then there being a bunch of people telling those superfans that it's a fucking movie, and of course they aren't going to cast someone who is *actively* ugly as a main character in something destined to make Cubic Terabucks in profits.

Does rather fuck up the female "Hero's Journey" of turning from an ugly duckling into a swan for the character, though.

Warmek's avatar

> …or I suppose it’s almost more of a Snamione dynamic?

*stares fifty in the mirror, noting the very grey beard*

"Fuck, that'd be 'Dumbldione' now, wouldn't it? Ew."

Warmek's avatar

> insufferably bossy beavergirl

Y'know, this phrase takes on a whole new meaning in light of the 18th birthday upskirt...

Warmek's avatar

> A few weeks ago I watched the first trailer for the new Harry Potter show slated for release later this year, which is pretty interestingly being marketed as a more faithful adaptation of the books.

Like... except for the parts where it's *GLARINGLY FUCKING NOT*?

The scene where the Marauders hang Snape in a tree during their time at Hogwarts is going to take on rather a *fresh* nuance in this series, innit?

Drunk Wisconsin's avatar

I liked this post before reading it because I assumed it was the long form version of that note, but you really managed to tie lots of different strands together really well here.

What I want to see is Harry and Ginny set up better. She's this little shy, introverted girl who develops a crush on him before puberty knocks her into sporty hot girl territory (remember, she was a Quidditch gangster) who ends up dating a big dick jock. But no matter how much she tries to move on and become a badass hottie with an attitude, there's this soft spot for the guy she never stopped crushing on who saved her. If you have that opposing Hermione Watson, you can form a conclusion other than "HP ❤️ HG"

Walt Bismarck's avatar

The weird thing is that she actually had a perfect way to do that--in books 3-4 she is the only one with a comparably personal tie to Voldemort, having been possessed by him for most of the second book, which would have given Harry a deeper bond with her realistically than either Ron or Hermione. So she could have been the main one to stick by him in early Book 5 for instance and push him into creating DA, and they also could have had Harry mentoring her for most of the early series with a payoff of her saving her mom from Bellatrix instead of vice versa. Instead she becomes a minor character randomly for books 3-5 and then pops into focus in book 6 completely out of nowhere which makes her feel kind of forced and flat and makes you root for HP/HG against the canonical romances, when I don't think anyone would have done if she'd just kept Ginny as a major character in the midseries books.

Prudence Sitwell's avatar

Really sound analysis of the books-to-film divergence. I always noticed the vibe shift from Columbus through Yates— the directors individually made huge differences that went unreversed. Each film took on a new aesthetic and narrative dimension that forced itself further and further away from the original text. (Also having to deal with the content, as Columbus’s aesthetic was obviously so faithful to the wondrous and childlike elements of books 1 and 2, contrastingly Yates dealt with the difficulties of the characters growing up in and eventually fighting in a wizarding race war.)

Emma is the square we can’t circle, as you so accurately hone in on her influence on Hermione’s character in ways JKR even now seems unconscious of. I have often wondered what would’ve happened if the books had been entirely published before the movies were released, or even if the movies were slightly less successful than they were. Would we have had a different Hermione, and were any narrative changes made under influence of the fandom, Warner Bros, the lucrative promises of record-breaking movie premiers?

lou lennox's avatar

Yes

Aristides's avatar

Great work! I always love essays that explain an annoying itch on the back of my mind that I didn’t have the words to eloquently explain. And yeah, the only reason I’m planning on watching the brew Harry Potter is to see if they give Ron and Hermione the chemistry they had in the books.

Trixie's Boy's avatar

I might as well and see how it goes for (at least the younger half of) the Zoomers and Generation Alpha and Beta. I may want to read the books fully some time. Hopefully I get that chance soon.

Greg's avatar
Oct 3Edited

The kid playing Hermione in the HBO series previously played the title role in the West End production of “Matilda,” so it’s not hard to guess what the producers were thinking when they cast her. They wanted a kid with experience playing an intelligent child, and who could make complicated dialogue sound natural. That she’s black is almost incidental - at least on paper, she’s an upgrade from Emma Watson at the same age. The series will still likely suck, but it won’t be her fault.

Marky Martialist's avatar

I’m so glad I never let myself drop down age groups and read or watch anything Potter. I’ve never consumed a single element of that media universe, and for what I do know about it via cultural osmosis, I’m better off.

But this was great analysis as far as I’m concerned, having watched some of the disputes during the early Rowling terf years. It makes perfect sense, and the stepdad regime is a good way of putting it: I’ve had empowered female characters thrown at me my entire adult life, but the current zeitgeist could only have become this much of a cartoon through what you’re talking about, a society of girls raised to digest it, a national writer’s room built to pander to it while thinking it’s counterculture, a gradual generational increase in navel-gazing solipsism until everyone who doesn’t follow the current thing is completely dehumanized.

This is a brutal takedown that only those with a long attention span and taste for the subtle damnation of disappointment can ever really grasp. They deserve it. Nice work.

Trixie's Boy's avatar

As a Zoomer I will tell you that I only managed to read the first few chapters of each book, and I would rather read a classic novel like Rebecca or The Magic Mountain.

So I am quite the opposite from where you're coming from and even though I watched all the movies, I was only a baby when the first Harry Potter came out.

Mark Goetz's avatar

fuck yeah, it's walt

Mark Goetz's avatar

everyone it's walt

Ouchie's avatar

Good lord man how long is this?

Andrew the not-quite-Grey's avatar

Interesting. Had not noticed it before but you are correct. In the books, Ron is the sidekick. He is also more often than not the initiator, despite feeling acutely the shadow of his more accomplished older brothers. Harry is not passive, but he is reactive. Almost everything he does is responding to events posed upon him or imitated by someone else.

From that perspective, it’s not surprising that Ron gets Hermione - who is very book smart, a little socially awkward (she spends most of her time hanging around with two boys rather than other girls), and motivated to try things - while Harry ends up with Ginny. Neither Harry nor Ginny are particularly initiators and both are within the other’s comfort zone.

For all his natural talent, Harry and Ginny are far more likely to end up being just members of their community while Ron and Hermione end up leading something.

Max Avar's avatar

Walt, you might enjoy Tom Felton’s autobiography (he’s the actor who played Draco Malfoy). He was older than the HRH actors and says that Emma Watson had a crush on him.

The contrast between women’s reactions to Draco Malfoy (a genuinely contemptible piece of human garbage) and Neville Longbottom (a genuinely admirable human being) was a huge redpill for me. If women find a man attractive, they will ignore his flaws and literally invent/discover fictitious good qualities for him to justify their feelings. (And then turn around and tell incels that they must not be getting laid because they’re bad human beings.)

Wilfred Stepto's avatar

I was expecting this article to discuss the fact that HBO is white-washing a brown girl. The woke commentators can't because they're ignoring the show because of Rowling.

Don't get me wrong, this is still an interesting exploration of auteur theory and how the movies influenced (for the worse) the later books.

Have the new showrunners issued a fatwa against discussing the new Hermione actress' race of which I am unaware?

Also, Black Snape is a strategic race-swap to distract from how white the rest of the cast remains. I shall explore this at a later date.

Wilfred Stepto's avatar

The fact that HBO has race-swapped only ONE of the 7-book characters is worth studying.

Siddhesh's avatar

Incredible read, wonder what you think of the current Malfoid trend on Twitter