Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Norman Eckart's avatar

Before people think Bismarck is off on a vanity project here, there are significant promotional reasons why an updoot-cabal would be incredibly profitable for those participating in it.

That the function is called a "Like" is misleading, as it is more a "Promote" button. There have been experiments done where as little as 10 updoots on a social media post within the first hour or two of its creation could be enough to tickle the algorithm into serving it up to a much-wider audience than otherwise. It's a form of priming the pump, guerilla marketing, and can be the difference between a forgotten flop and a viral success. It has little to do with actual emotions and more a decision by the reader, "Would you like more people to see this?"

The black-hat technique is to just hire bot farms or bio-bot Indians to do the updooting. But recruiting from genuine supporters and encouraging networked support is just a tactic that many good and independent creators do to carve out that initial priming. It's simply a more organized form of telling people to "Like and Subscribe", or enticing bigger-names to promote your material, or the general Substack reminders to do so in virtually every article. Making these organized groups is incredibly common among independent authors, who are often fans plied with review-copies in return for their honest reviews, shares, and updoots. When done these ways, it preserves the foundational purpose of the Like button, which is to promote things genuine people find valuable enough to click an extra button over.

I regularly comment on Bismarck articles because I am interested enough to read them and enjoy the thoughts they inspire, and also because it purges my feed of much unwanted dross polluting it. I accidentally poison it myself by succumbing to the urge to reply to opinions I dislike on occasion. By carefully curating a group of based gentlemen (and ladies) who actively interact with Bismarck's work, the algorithm on Substack at least will start associating them together and direct readers to that net of content more frequently. That in itself is a potential value proposition for both updooter and creator.

Anyway, it's a fair plan and, even now, people can see the fruits of at least imploring people quite directly to Like things in social media.

Expand full comment
Your Name's avatar

We just don’t like *you*. Your shit is insightful enough to read, you’re just not likable.

Expand full comment
27 more comments...

No posts